New Years Lists – FRC Team’s Worst Films of 2011
So yesterday we talked about the films we loved of 2011, the ones that left us a little or a lot different. Today we are talking about the films that made us plain angry, The WORST films of the year.
There has undoubtedly been a fair few stinkers this year, as with most years. I don’t think I have actually walked out of a theatre at all, but it has come close. Many of the films we have been most upset with have been subject of a very heavy marketing campaign. Maybe if the Production companies left a little to our imagination with the trailers and poster we may have different expectations when we go into the cinema. Just a thought.
Anyway I am waffling on, here are our pick of the films that left us wishing we hadn’t spent the money not only on the ticket, but also the parking, and popcorn….
FRC Team’s Worst Films of 2011
Scott Lawlor
5 – Colombiana
You will see a common theme running through my least loved films. Quite often I have enjoyed a good trailer but then been left flat and empty by a shoddy story, Colombiana is a fine example of this. It starts off well but when we have to witness a free running child escaping from many cartel soldiers all belief goes out of the window. The whole story just did not work for me at all. I left the cinema almost to the point of swearing. Miss Saldana is pretty in the face but she really needs a good meal!!
4 – Sucker Punch
See here we go again. I bought into the trailer BIG time with this one. But when I got to the film I was just left with a mess that felt empty and made no sense. I wanted to like it but it felt like a teenage boys wet dream. Such a shame, as stylistically it is stunning.
3 – Cowboys & Aliens
My screening of this will probably go down as one of the worst ones I have had this year. I just wanted to leave after 30 mins, but I couldn’t get out as I was with friend and the cinema was fairly full. The film made little sense, but it also took itself far to seriously. It would have been much better as a straight Western. Also the Cowboys were very matter of fact about an alien race coming down to Earth. Awful.
2 – Battle L.A.
This just goes to prove that a big budget and lots of explosions doe not make a good film. I was hoping for Black Hawk Down meets Independence day, What I got was a bunch of OOH RAHHing marines and un believable Aliens. The musical score was so bad as well. Battle L.A. is like a serious version of Team America World Police!!
1 – Justice
Oh My Days!! I actually fell asleep in this one. Only for a couple of minutes but it was just SOOOO boring. I feel bad for Nic Cage as I could have so easily of had 3 of my 5 with him in (Season of the Witch and Trespass) but I had to be kind to the old goat. Add the awful acting skills of January Jones and you have a film that is worse than pulling teeth with a pair of pliers.
Mike Williams
5 – Green Lantern
Stupid.Stupid.Stupid. Plus the fact that Thor and X Men: First Class was actually quite good, which made it seem even worse.
4 – The Dilemma
Kevin James and Vince Vaughn: probably the most annoying ‘comedy actors’ past their sell-by-date.
3 – Zookeeper
Not even the delightfully tasty Leslie Bibb can make this appealing. Her character stinks. The whole thing stinks like an unflushed turd. Plus it stars Kevin James. Enough said.
2 – Transformers 3
Awful self-indulgent garbage. Michael Bay does what he does best: makes a child’s toy sexualised, blows everything to smithereens, indulge in his favourite 360 and slow motion shots. I could go on, but I’ll stop before I begin to discuss the hour-long ‘final fight’ scene…
1 – Cowboys & Aliens
The biggest let down of 2011 for me. The trailer seemed rather good, but as The Village proved: a trailer can be mightily deceptive. This stinks. Harrison Ford and Daniel Craig look tired and confused throughout, and frankly I don’t blame them
Teri Williams
5 – The Thing
I didn’t actually hate this film as much as I did the others on this list, but I did find it slightly pointless, boring and a little insulting to the original feature that it prequels and its source material. Mary Elizabeth Winstead was, however, its saving grace – she’s lovely. A waste of talent in a lacklustre movie.
4 – I Don’t Know How She Does It
Am I allowed to add in a film that I stopped watching after forty minutes because it was that bad? Sexist: check. Boring: check. Sarah Jessica Parking: infuriating and patronizing. I think that about sums it up. If anyone thinks I should watch the rest, please make your case now – I’m yet to be convinced.
3 – Limitless
I didn’t really want to see Limitless, so my opinion of it was doomed from the start. I think Bradley Cooper is awful, and his smug, pointy face makes me want to punch cute things. Limitless felt too long, too surfacey, and was more style than true substance.
2 – Horrible Bosses
I wanted to like this film so much. I love Jason Bateman, I have a huge crush on Jason Sudeikis, and anything with a cast member from It’s Always Sunny In Philadelphia will draw me in. It was too silly, not genuinely hilarious enough given its amusing premise, and a little try-hard – and Jennifer Aniston’s character was, quite frankly, terrifying. There were a lot of funnier, discerning mainstream comedies of 2011 – avoid this and pick up Bridesmaids or 50/50 instead.
1 – Source Code
Don’t get me wrong – I love myself a good popcorn movie, but Jake Gyllenhaal is not as convincing an action star as he wants to be. I found this film to be verbose, predictable and overall, disappointing, considering it was brought to us by the same man who gave us Moon. It left me cold.
Tom Bielby
This was a really difficult list to compile, I tend to avoid films that are not too my taste and receive bad reviews, and therefore I couldn’t think of a single film that has been released this year which did not have a single redeeming feature out of those I watched. I’m not saying that 2011 was an incredible year for films (although it has been pretty good!) but I have been very lucky in the films that I have seen. I also approach film criticism with a view that even if the overall product is not to my taste, I can appreciate great cinematography, original ideas, and solid acting if they exist in isolation. None of the films listed below are as bad as The Flintstones, Batman & Robin or Van Helsing and do all have at least one redeeming feature but they all left me disappointed and I doubt I will ever be watching them again:
5. Colombiana
This action film was okay to watch, with a large number of engaging and inventive action scenes but the storyline bordered on the ridiculous far too often, and I was forced to stifle my laughter numerous times which I am sure was not the director’s intentions.
4. Immortals
Tarsem Singh’s The Fall is one of my favourite films, its breathtaking visuals and heartbreakingly poignant story is a testament to his skill as a director, and as such I was eager to see how he would follow this up. Whilst Immortals looked as stunning as The Fall, the story was muddled, the acting was stiff and it ultimately failed to entertain.
3. West is West
East is East was an excellent bitter-sweet comedy that never fails to have me in stitches. West is West was a dull and lifeless attempt to emulate the success of the original and it completely missed the mark. An insult to fans of the original.
2. The Silent House
This horror film from Uruguay was supposedly filmed in one entire take which would be an impressive feat if the film was worth watching. The story is contrived with a ridiculous twist that is a shame when considering the intriguing premise. This is one found footage film too far, and that is coming from a huge horror fan. I bought this on blu-ray as well, what a waste of my hard-earned cash!
1. Fair Game
Fair game gets the accolade of the most boring film I have seen this year. The trailer sold it as a political thriller with heaps of action but it was a dull drama that failed to engage me or the person sitting next to me in the cinema who did the right thing and fell asleep. Naomi Watts and Sean Penn are two great actors but even their solid performances were not enough to rescue the film, it would be wise to avoid Fair Game at all costs.
What were your worst films for the year? Have we missed any? Comment below…





























































Usually when I see those worst-of-the-year lists I can contratulate myself on having avoided yet another five terrible movies. It’s very rare that I’ve watched anything that is listed. But Teri’s list took me completely by surprisde. Source Code! What? While it’s probably not on my top 10 list (the competition is tough this year), it’s surely on my top 25. A clear 4/5. Limitless wasn’t quite as good but still a decent view, a 3,5/5 nice Friday entertainment movie. Someone here clearly doesn’t like sci-fi….
But I guess that’s what makes a list more fun to read – when you have something to disagree with.
HAHA I know what you mean Jessica about worst of lists, I unfortunately have seen far too many films this year and there is bound to be some awful ones in there!!
As for Source Code, I must admit I enjoyed it mostly, except the ending, I hated that. But I respect having it one there. It did have it’s flaws.
I do love how FILM can be taken so differently by people.
I have a friend who walked out of Midnight in Paris, yet I loved it!!
I am as surprised as Jessica. I almost take pride in not watching any movie in worst film of year lists. But, after Source Code here, I feel like I have lost my thing.
But, I agree with Scott as well. I did not like the ending at all. I rated it 6/10 on IMDb.
I was surprised by Teri’s list as well, I enjoyed limitless and Horrible Bosses despite their flaws but am yet to see Source Code. Being a huge sci-fi fan and as it is directed by Duncan Jones I will still give it a watch.
Sorry guys. Maybe it deserves a rewatch, if I can bring myself to do so. Like Scott, I absolutely hated the ending.
And by the way, I love sci-fi.
I quite like the fact you’ve put it as your worst Teri cause I will now be going in with lower expectations so it could work out to my favour! I shall let you know what I make of it when I get round to watching it.
I’d really like to know what you think of it! I had a feeling people would be surprised by me adding it onto this list, but I felt at the same time I couldn’t lie by keeping it off. Different strokes…
Great Lists again Guys! Thanks for taking part in this one and sharing your most hated.
Some Surprises but also some firm hated… C&A and Colombiana were plain awful for sure!!
I have caused an enormous amount of controversy, Scott…
HAHA I love it!! Your list is the most personal of the group that is for sure!!
I think I’m going to name these films as the worst of 2011: Transformers 3, Battle: LA and Cowboys & Aliens, I really hated those films equally.
Awesome list!
Haven’t seen any of those – fair warning, thanks Ted! I’m sad not even Daniel Craig can save such a turkey :’(
An other eclectic mix here! I am a bit surprised with SOURCE CODE, I loved it! But COWBOYS & ALIENS seemed a common consensus!
I was also tempted to buy FAIR GAME the other day, I am now a tad sceptical, but I do have insatiable love for Naomi Watts..
I also love Naomi Watts Mike but even she couldn’t rescue the film for me. Having said that, political thrillers are not my favourite choice of film so there may be something in it for you.
There needs to be more Sucker Punch hate in the world. It really is ‘sick up in your hand’ bad. I walked out of the film 9-10 times in a single showing, mainly as they were giving away free ice cream in the foyer, but also because I like flouncing out of things if I can.
I also hated Horrible Bosses, 30 Minutes Or Less, and most of Black Swan.
I enjoyed Source Code, surprised it’s on someone’s worst list.
I am still waiting for the blu-ray release of 30 mins to unleash on that one!!
Happy New Year Ant!!
I knew everyone would think I’m a flippin’ idiot for putting Source Code on there. But I am sticking by my list – matter of opinion and all that, I just didn’t like it. My eyes were rolling through the whole thing, I’m surprised I wasn’t removed from the cinema
Haven’t seen Sucker Punch and have no intentions of doing so. The poster made me want to gag…
Hi, Teri:
I thought that Source Code was an altered just enough to avoid lawsuits re-hash of an equally obtuse and poorly executed Deja Vu from 2006.
Still don’t know why Sarah Jessica Parker continues to be in films. She can only be shot from one angle. Isn’t much of a Clothes Horse and has less talent than the family of stray cats I feed to keep my back yard free of moles.
And yes. Stay away from Sucker Punch !
Scottie, that JUSTICE must be really bad since I haven’t even heard about it LOL
And Tom will get spanked by me for putting IMMORTALS in this list. He will feel the wrath of Titans!
I am desperate to see Immortals. It looks like the best piece of cheese there ever was.
Haha I knew someone would comment about the inclusion of Immortals, maybe my expectations were too high but after the brilliance of The Fall I was really disappointed.
Hi, Scott, Mike, Teri, Tom and company:
And Hollywood wonders why 2011 was a lackluster year for film attendance?
Lots of big buck offerings bit the dust with little fanfare. Proving yet again that good looking trailers which basically encapsulate a film, do not necessarily make for Good Cinema.
Not at all surprised to see Columbiana, Green Lantern, Sucker Punch, I Don’t Know How She Does It , The Thing and Fair Game on the list. Though I am pondering the absence of In Time ..
At least now I have an idea of what will be on HBO’s, Starz and Encore’s playbill for 2012.
Hi JD, thanks for stopping by and injecting a little of your knowledge here!!
I completely forgot about In Time. that was also very very bad!!
Happy New Year my friend
Awesome and interesting listing FRC team.
I have said it on other blogs I apparently did not get out enough this year to see everything. But can say this without reservation – Battle LA was a turkey and a half. My word!
It seems like Sucker Punch lived up to its title in terms of what it delivered those unfortunate enough to sit in the cinema to watch.
Scott: Justice? I do not even think I have heard of that film! Poor Guy Pearce (not need to pity Nic Cage at this point).
And Mike – are you trying to tell us something about Kevin James?
HAHA Justice came and went here very quickly too, but not quick enough for me NOT to see it, which was a shame!!
Yes it was a bit of a sell out for Guy Pearce!! Ah well on to 2012
Thanks for the comment matey
I don’t see anything there that I disagree with.
There are also a fair few here that I started to watch, but couldn’t finish. Sucker Punch, Battle L.A., Green Hornet, and Columbiana would top my worst list this year.
The only one of these I watched all the way through was The Silent House, and that was a real disappointment too. But I didn’t turn it off or walk away so it gets at least a passing grade from me.
I wish I had turned them off too!! BUt I just hope for a glimmer of something that would be entertaining
A fun batch of end of year lists, guys. It engendered a bunch of “Oh hell Yeah!” (Battle:L.A., Transformers 3) and “Oh, No!” (Source Code) moments, but reading your thoughts for why they made it on to these was well worth the read. It certainly made me curious for some of the films I’ve not yet seen. Thanks for this, and Happy New Year one and all.
Happy New Year Matey!! And I am glad we entertained you with this one!!
Happy New Year FRC staff!
Wow matey, I’m glad I have not seen any from your top 5 worst list!! I still might rent C&A but no way would I spend $ seeing on the big screen.
Tom, I so agree w/ Fair Game being so boring. Fortunately I saw that for free at a local film fest last year. I’m generally not a fan of Sean Penn and this movie won’t change my opinion, he’s just such a surly actor, though Naomi is still quite watchable. I agree The Fall is still the better film from Tarsem but there are still lots going for it in Immortals (read: Henry Cavill) that I won’t put that in my worst list
Luckily Ruth we didn’t spend money on seeing it either!! Yeay for Press screenings… booo for rubbish films!
I’m surprised about placing SOURCE CODE on there. I truly liked the film
Thanks for the comment matey!!
Interesting about Source Code. I thought that film was fantastic, but I have kinda forgotten about it as the year goes on. But trust me, there are worse films out there: The Roommate, Something Borrowed, Your Highness…you guys are extremely lucky if you missed out on those horrible films.
And I’ll be the minority who actually really enjoyed Limitless. Sure, it didn’t reach it’s full potential but I thought it was quite entertaining. Same with Horrible Bosses.
Still, glad to see some hate for Cowboys & Aliens, Transformers 3 and Sucker Punch. They were not good at all!
Stevee I felt the same about limitless, and Horrible Bosses.
Thanks for the comment matey!!
fun list. I already know Sucker Punch is doomed to be an awful movie the moment I saw the poster. I thought Colombiana was great when I saw the trailer, I guess I was wrong. I haven’t seen any movie in that list…hehe I better avoid them now
Hi Novia!!
Thanks for stopping by
Yeah I would miss Colombiana if possible!!
What a great selection of the worst films of 2011!
As I read through the list I found just more and more films that I agreed with, and the ones that I haven’t seen yet I have only heard terrible things about!
Scott – The ones out of your list that I agree whole heartedly with are COLOMBIANA and BATTLE:LA.
COLOMBIANA was one that I bought into from the trailer and couldn’t wait to watch it, I made it through the first 20 minutes and had to call it. The moment that the girl was deftly able to launch herself out of a high-rise apartment building and escape unscathed brought my suspension of disbelief to a grinding halt.
As for BATTLE:LA it works as a flick only when the sound is turned down because it has one of the worst scripts and dialogue that I’ve seen in any movie. It is absolutely moronic!
Mike – I couldn’t agree more with the inclusions of GREEN LANTERN and TRANSFORMERS 3!
GREEN LANTERN is abismal. I saw it on a plane, well part of it, I think I made it to the first 30 minutes and then I was brain-dead so I needed to switch it off and just stare into space which was so much more enjoyable!
Oh TRANSFORMERS 3…I hate you with the passion of a thousand suns. It was bad on every single level. I think it might just be the worst movie I have ever had the misfortune to have ever seen. I am just upset with myself that I stayed all the way through it, I should have just walked out!
Hi Russell!! It is great to know that even on the other side of the world there is a guy with the same taste in film as I!! Thanks for the comment matey and I wish you a happy new year!!
I loved Source Code and Fair Game. However i do agree with the hate for Transformers 3.
Happy New Year Julian!!
I think you’re all being a little tough on Cowboys & Aliens. It wasn’t that bad surely? I thought it was pretty enjoyable while watching it but totally forgettable rather than bad. Or is there a backlash because we all expected it to be much better?
HAHA I understand Louise… but for this film lover it was horrid!! and a yawn fest!
This is one of those lists that I’m glad to say I haven’t seen the movies listed. Not very often that happens. I will try to avoid these films going forward. Thanks Scott and Co.
I do have a problem with Source Code being listed as well. While it isn’t as good as Moon, it was one of the highlights of the beginning of 2011.
You are very welcome Max!! Happy New Year!
For some reason, I never realized that Michelle Monaghan was wearing such a short skirt in Source Code or I would have paid more attention to the movie lol.
I didn’t think Cowboys & Aliens was horrible, it just was completely forgettable because it was so undaring. Disappointing movie, given the title.
HAHA Trust you Castor!! But yes that is a very short skirt… hubba hubba
I remember your review very clearly now matey, of C&A I mean.
Thanks very much for stopping by
I actually can agree with Teri on Source Code, while I did not hate it my expectations were so high I would definitely put it in my top 5 least favorites. I suppose when seeing a movie where your expectations are is everything.
Cowboys and Aliens is easily my number 1 worst though…
Good lists guys!!
Hi Matt!! Thanks for popping in and leaving a comment. Very kind of you.
Nice to see someone else agreeing with Source code!!
Have a cracking 2012 my friend
You too Scott!
hahaha what a great list! I agree with most of these, while I find that I still like at least one on everyone’s list!
Glad to see Colombiana here, along with Zookeeper, and Green Lantern.
and, yes, Nicolas Cage HAD to be represented here somehow!
hehe T. I nearly had a complete 5 of Nic Cage films!! He has had a bad yet very bust year!!
Happy New One my friend
Very interesting lists! So glad to see someone else as appalled by The Silent House as I was. That was my worst film of the year and Tom has hit the nail on the head. Absolute shite. Terrible, terrible film. I’m still a little angry about it.
Probably won’t bother with Colomiana now as I also won’t be bothering with I am Number Four after seeing it on so many ‘worst’ lists.
Very surprised to see Source Code and Limitless on ‘worst of’ lists… especially Source Code . Has Teri seen ‘The Silent House’. Perhaps that could at least SC into number 2!?
Hi Pete. Thanks for popping in and commenting.
I have yet to see Silent House, and I am pretty pleased about that now with all the hate flying around!! HAHA
Happy New year my friend
Definitely an interesting collection of lists you guys came up with. Can’t say I have seen most of them, but I rather enjoyed Source Code, Limitless and Horrible Bosses. Not surprised to see Cowboys & Aliens listed more than once, heh.
Happy New Year Eric!!
C&A was so bad, which is such a shame as I really wanted it to be good!!!
Ouch for Colombiana – I’ll avoid that one then.
I think Source Code could have been a lot better but perhaps not worthy of the number one worst film of 2011. Then again, as these lists show, there were some truly horrid Hollywood films – Battle L.A. was certainly one of them.
HAHA Yes Dan, stay well clear of Colombiana… for my sake!!
Anybody seen the recently released “The Darkest Hour”? I thought that was pretty bad too…
Hi Asrap!!
Thanks for the comment matey. I haven’t seen that one yet. It is not out here, but the trailer looked pretty bad if I am honest!
Hi Scott, love that line ‘Battle L.A. is like a serious version of Team America World Police!!’ Harsh but from what I could tell from the general reaction to it, a fair comment. (Can something be harsh and fair at the same time? Not sure.) Anyways, I enjoyed you and the guy’s lists though I was shocked and appalled to see Source Code make a ‘worst’ list. I’m sorry, but was Teri smoking something funny that day? I mean seriously, Source Code was one of the few original ideas to come out of the cinema in 2011. That’s movies for you, one dude’s Citizen Kane is another dude’s Battlefield Earth! N.B. I am not comparing Source Code to Citizen Kane… for illustration purposes only.
HAHAH Thanks Ronan. I actually edited that line quite a bit so as not to offend anyone!!
I am proud of Teri for sticking to her guns!! She didn’t like it and it is her list!!
I must admit I enjoyed it, but that is not saying her opinion is wrong.
Thanks for commenting my mate!
My sentiments exactly, we wouldn’t be movie blogger if we all didn’t occasionally spout comments or reviews that rub our fellow bloggers up the wrong way. That’s half the fun! Good post Scott.
I haven’t seen a single one of these. I suppose I should be grateful for that fact.
HAHAH Yes you should Mr LaRue!! You should be very happy!
Haha, every worst films of the year rating should have at least one Nicolas Cage film I guess.
I love your opinion on Battle L.A. (like most of your commentators, but it’s true- it is the perfect interpratation) and I too hated it (because nothing literally happens in this film- there are no characters, just shooting).
As a fan of bad films though I am very tempted by this list. I haven’t seen Cowboys and Aliens but I heard only bad reviews and I really regret that this film didn’t turn amazing like I hoped it would.
Hi Katie, thanks for stopping in and commenting. Very kind of you to do so!!
You are so right about B:LA, it was ALLLLL SHOOTING!! HAHAH
Please stay away from C&A… it is a snooze fest!
Im just so glad someone put Source Code as their worst movie. I so agree with your Teri. Not too happy about Sucker Punch or Green Lantern being in the list.
I was reading this thinking “Brilliant, I agree with all of these!” and then woah, woah, WOAH! Source Code?! That’s one of my favourites! Each to their own but sort of shocked me, not heard many bad things to that. Unless I was only reading/hearing selectively.
Great piece though, Sucker Punch and Battle of LA are totally on my list
Apparently Justice is a thing.
for me the absolute worst is definetly “Horrible Bosses” what an awful picture. Surprised to see “Source Code” and “Limitless” here and no “Conan the Barbarian”, “The Iron Lady” or “One Day”. I agree about January Jones’s acting skills – she has none.
Like many I didn’t have much to contribute to this when yall wrote this cos I tend to avoid bad cinema releases all together in a blind haze; the lazy privelege of those who aren’t taking on the admirable responsibility of film journalism in order to advise everyone else on the good n the bad.
But, today I bother to sit down to I Don’t Know Why [sorry, 'How'] She Does It. And I almost black out in red mist.
Teri, you are missing nothing by stopping at the 40 minute mark. NOTHING AT ALL. By the end of it I was quite ready to punch SJP right in her regressive face. And I still am. And probably will be for the rest of my life. She’s a crime against feminism.