Thursday List – The Ten: Best Actors of All Time – Relay Race
For this weeks list it is FRCs turn to take the baton in the latest craze going around, The Ten: Best Actors of All Time – Relay Race.
Many of you that frequent here will know Nostra of MyFilmViews. He has been called in the past the ‘King of Blog Series’, and it is very true. He does have the uncanny knack of coming up with original ideas for series / memes / blogathons. I am super jealous.
Well this is the latest one – The Ten: Best Actors of All Time!!! But what does this even mean? Well here is the low down…
So what’s the idea behind the relay? I’ve created a list of what I think are the best actors. At the end of the post I, just like in a real relay race, hand over the baton to another blogger who will write his own post. This blogger will have to remove one actor (that is an obligation) and add his own choice and describe why he/she did this. At the end the blogger chooses another blogger to do the same. The idea is to make this a long race, so that enough bloggers get a chance to remove and add an actor. We will end up with a list (not ranked in order) which represents a common agreement of the best actors.
Got it? Good. I would like to thank Terence from The Focused Filmographer for bestowing FRC with the baton this week. You devil you!!
So I have to remove one actor from the list and replace it with a choice of my own. Now this seems an easy task but take a look at the list. They are ALL heavy hitters! Who would I remove and replace?
My choice is at the bottom. I am sure I will get flamed by many for removing who I did. But hey, this is the beauty of blogging!! The Freedom of speech hey? (Do not panic my initial joke choice of Jason Statham didn’t pan out!!)
Here we go…
Robert De Niro
Although he may not have had any roles that stood out in the last couple of years, he has proven what an amazing actor he is. Just think of his roles in Taxi Driver, Raging Bull, The Godfather: Part II, Goodfellas, The Untouchables, Heat and Cape Fear.
Samuel L Jackson
Probably the hardest working actor around, with 139 roles to his name, he has proven to be an actor that can take on any type of role and make it convincing. Whether it is a small role of a drug addict or big role as a hitman, he always manages to give it his all. Some of his movies include Pulp Fiction, The Long Kiss Goodnight, Jackie Brown, The Negotiator and Unthinkable.
Daniel Day Lewis
Although he might not have appeared in as many movies as some of the other actors in this list he makes up for it in the amazing performances he gives. He really disappears in his roles. Some of his best work includes My Left Foot, There Will Be Blood, Gangs of New York, In the Name of the Father and Last of the Mohicans.
Charlie Chaplin
Now this might not be someone you’d immediately think of, but when it comes to comedy and silent movies he was perfect, funny and knew exactly how to make his audience care about the character he played. Some of his best work can be enjoyed in The Kid, City Lights, The Great Dictator and Modern Times.
Gary Oldman
He has proven that he is a true chameleon, with a very distinct look in every movie he appears in. His acting is always a joy to watch. Some of his best known work is that in the Harry Potter series, Leon, Tinker Tailor Soldier Spy, the latest Batman movies and Dracula.
Philip Seymour Hoffman
He started acting in 1991 and really has had a very versatile career appearing in movies that are loved in art houses, but in mainstream movies as well. His movies include The Ides of March, Synecdoche, New York, Charlie Wilson’s War, Capote and Magnolia.
Marlon Brando
Now I must admit that I haven’t seen many of his movies, but he was stunning in his most famous role in The Godfather, but also roles in Apocalypse Now, On The Waterfront and A Streetcar Named Desire he wowed audiences.
Robert Duvall
Robert Duvall has had an amazing career as well. I don’t know much about his early work, but I always enjoy to see him on the screen. His characters always are injected with something that grounds them into reality. He appeared in movies like Get Low, The Godfather, Colors, Apocalypse Now and THX1138.
Christian Bale
With quite the diverse range in roles, Oscar-winner Christian Bale goes to great lengths for many of his roles. From losing weight to almost unhealthy standards twice (The Machinist, The Fighter) to taking dance and martial arts lessons for 10 weeks for Newsies (a film which he dislikes), Bale consistently goes to incredible lengths to bring a role to life. Other examples of his great work include: Batman Begins, The Dark Knight, The Prestige, Empire of the Sun, Equilibrium, and 3:10 to Yuma.
MY CHOICE
Paul Giamatti
This is a guy who can do anything. He is the everyman of actors. From insane villains to hen-pecked husbands on the brink of depression. He has great comedic timing as well as some fantastic dramatic chops. From Win Win to Barney’s Version to Ides of March (which he owned) to Sideways. I could watch this guy paint walls and still be enthralled.
WHO I REPLACED
Al Pacino
Now I know I am going to get flamed for this. But take a look at the list, they are all heavy hitters. All big names, all deserving of a place on this list. Although I liked Pacino in his earlier work, his gravelly voice and the fact that he seems to shout his lines in his latest roles kind of pushed me over the edge… Also Jack and Jill people… JACK AND FRICKING JILL!!
So now it is time for me to pass the BATON onto another blogger who has to replace one member of the list with a choice of their own. For that one I will choose Pete from ‘I Love That Film’.So come on Pete get thinking!! You have a week!!
About The Author – Scott Lawlor
Chief Editor of FRC. A self confessed geek with an unhealthy thirst for all things Home Cinema. Whether it is the latest Action film or Subwoofer. Check out his home set up HERE
Who would you have chosen? Would you have replaced someone else? Comment below…




















































Not seen this meme yet – what a fantastic idea. I’ve been toying with the idea of doing a top ten list of actors for a while but too over-whelmed by the choices in front of me.
Agree with taking Al Pacino off the list and for me much of the same applies to De Niro – brilliant early work has been replaced with lazy pastiches of those early roles. One Focker film was fine, three was too much.
Agreed. Get De Niro off this list pronto. He had some good early stuff but in my opinion he is THE MOST OVERRATED actor of all time.
Also Christian Bale is on this list? Seriously?
Kudos for putting Duvall in here though. Pretty underrated and often times forgotten. Not to mention the lengthy lengthy filmography legacy. Oldman and Hoffman are high up there as well.
HAHA I have a feeling Bale won’t be on for long…. or will he?
Thanks Louise, I am sure the baton will make it to you at some point!!
Holy cow! What an honour! Thanks Scott, I feel all warm inside! I’ll get to this on the weekend! As for Pacino, I’m with you. He’s great but when was the last time I saw him give a great performance? The 70s I think. Good call on Giamatti too, he elevates everything… especially semi-crap like Ironclad and Shoot ‘em Up!
Yeay!! I was hoping you would pop in and see I passed it on to you Pete. I was worried I was going to have to HUNT you down!!
I look forward to your changes coming up soon!
Great pick Scott! I’m sure someone will put Pacino back on the list. But can’t fault your choice of Giamatti. He has had so many great roles. Guess I should feature him in one of my Many Faces of posts…
I had the feeling you might have put Gosling on the list
Yes I know Pacino is going to cause a stirring. But to be honest it is hard to choose any!!
I wondered who you though I was going to put on there Although Gosling is good, he is not great… YET
Interesting concept I was just telling my brother about Marlon Brando and that it seems that since his passing, there are rumblings out there with some questioning his stature in many an ‘all time’ lists.
I personally like Brando and I think what he did when he curst onto the scene was to forever change screen acting; we can debate whether or not that was good or bad for films overall. It is an interesting discussion to have.
The other thing is that there is the inevitable curse of longevity (see Pacino, DeNiro for reference points/film credits). It seems Sam Jackson has avoided this all together by mixing up his CV to the point that you expect some less conventional choices (read Snakes on a Plane) to be mixed with straight-laced, ‘actorly’ pieces.
You make some very interesting points there Iba. Thanks for joining in. I am sure the baton will be passed your way at some point in the future!!
A GREAT choice Scott! I wanted to add Giamatti so bad. Glad that you undertook that task! I love his work.
And, ya know, you bring up a good point about Pacino. I agree with Nostra though in that I’m sure he will find his way back on this list.
btw, good job on keeping Bale! Go Team Batman!!! haha
Can’t wait to see what Pete’s got for us. The race continues!
HAHAH I felt kind obliged to keep Bale on T. You is me mate after all!!
Hi, Scott and company:
Okay, I’m beginning to understand a bit more the rules of this relay race,
Your logic is solid regarding Mr. Pacino. Who had made his mark. Writ large under the direction of Schatzberg, Coppola, Lumet and De Palma.
Within the last decade? Besides, ‘Heat’? Not so much.
Good catch on Paul Giamatti. A solid character actor. Very much like Peter Boyle for this generation.
Also, Christian Bale. Who’s spent his life in film. Continuously honed in craft to become a solid A-Lister today.
PS: I’ll have a Guest Review of Charles Laughton’s ‘The Night of the Hunter’ over at Ruth’s ‘FlixChatter’ later today. All are invited to drop by, peruse and comment!
Thanks Jack. I will head over to Flixy in a bit!! and have a good old read!!
This is an interesting idea huh?
You’re replacing Al Pacino? Well he does loss his shine nowadays…too bad.
HAHA I am!! But he can be put back by someone in the future!
Y’know I like this choice and Giamatti is definitely a GREAT underrated actor, not flashy but ALWAYS delivered, even in tiny roles!
Btw, it’s me who called Nostra ‘King of Blog Series’ but he certainly lives up to that name
I am sorry Ruth, I forgot to credit you with the title. I knew it was you but forgot to mention… forgive me?
ed harris should get a mention
Indeed he should! He may well make an appearance as this goes on!
i would replace samuel l jackson with denzel washington, christian bale with viggo mortensen and i think jack nicholson deserves an honorable mention at least
All good additions matey!!
thanks for the comment.
Brilliant choice! Really pleased that Paul Giamatti is in that list now…. I really enjoyed Sideways, I thought that it was a fantastic film and even in Shoot ‘Em Up I enjoy Giamatti’s performance.
As you said, the man really can do anything and everything. He is very funny when he needs to be and also puts in great dramatic performances.
Top choice.
Thanks Josh. I am super pleased you approve. I was worried as it is hard to replace any of these big hitters!
Gotta love Paul Giamatti. He is a highlight in every film he’s in. Nice choice, Scott!
Thanks Eric!! I am pleased you approve too!
Have recently discovered how great Giamatti is after watching Win Win. It’s a nice choice, Scott!
Yeah Andina, he is amazing in Win Win!!
Oh wow, certainly a controversial move. I’m just going to say that if Pacino is not here at the end, I will force the last blogger to pass the baton to me so I can put him back on….haha
All joking aside. I respect your decision because you have put the spotlight on a very underrated actor who should have at least three Oscar nominations by now. I absolutely love and respect Giamatti. Again, a very good choice, just not one I would measure up against Pacino.
Sure, none of us can disagree on the poor choices Pacino has made in the last few years of his career. It’s been said many times how hard is to remain relevant in Hollywood and I’m sure Pacino has tried and failed as of late. Not everyone can stay at the top of their game forever and being a part of Jack & Jill is a sin he can’t run away from.
I also agree with what you say about how he has developed this very particular style of acting that has just turned into a habit that he can’t seem to shake off. I’m still hoping he closes his career with another great film.
All of those things considered, it’s hard to find an actor with the resume of Pacino. The guy was the central figure of the greatest trilogy in movie history, he was awesome in Dog Day Afternoon, Carlito’s Way, Scarface, Heat and Serpico, all great films by the way.
I also thought he was fun as hell in Scent of a Woman and Dick Tracy, even when these films are not as good as the aforementioned.
There is also his underrated performance in The Insider and The Merchant of Venice, both more recent films he’s been a part of. At the end it all comes down to Michael Corleone. He’s the only one that can say he was Michael Corleone and there can’t ever be another one.
Giamatti is more deserving than Samuel L. Jackson!
I do like to mix it up. I almost put Statham on the list just to really throw the cat amongst the pigeons.
You make a great case. Maybe you will get the baton and put Pacino back on? Who knows!! It is a race after all!!
Thanks for the comment matey
Love this idea! Will be following it round while it does the rounds.
A big smile stretched across my face when I saw Gary Oldman on the list. Hugely deserving. Definitely a chameleon. Never disappointed by him.
Not sure about Giamatti. I dunno, but i’ve never really been all that captured by him.
Sadly, I can’t help myself but think of Brit comedian Adam Riches whenever I hear/read the name Daniel Day Lewis. The actor is forever comedy-ified for me!
Brando and Oldman, who can deny
I like your list, it’s very good and I agree with most of it, although I am not very familiar with all of Robert Duvall’s work, so maybe I would replace him with someone else, and also Philip Seymour Hoffman- great actor, but there are better out there (Morgan Freeman?Jack Nicholson?)
I love this idea! And Paul Giamatti is a great choice, Scott. I salute you.